Quickkill0 Posted October 24, 2009 Report Posted October 24, 2009 Ok you wanted "Constructive Criticism" so here it is. 1. The bulky buttons make the app look horrible the overplayed use of devcomponets doesn't help much either.2. You're settings scheme is really bad, there's no point in setting them if you close the app and open it again they just reset.3. The login form is pointless and irritating for long time users because it just gets in the way and doesn't serve a purpose on the account that you didn't obfuscate you're app so everyone can see you're "Private" password. Also none of which is in this app is "You're" research.You may have coded it but all of that stuff was figured out before you.There's a difference. Take this how you may but this is only for you to improve if you so choose so. 1
halodu03de Posted October 24, 2009 Author Report Posted October 24, 2009 (edited) Ok you wanted "Constructive Criticism" so here it is. 1. The bulky buttons make the app look horrible the overplayed use of devcomponets doesn't help much either.2. You're settings scheme is really bad, there's no point in setting them if you close the app and open it again they just reset.3. The login form is pointless and irritating for long time users because it just gets in the way and doesn't serve a purpose on the account that you didn't obfuscate you're app so everyone can see you're "Private" password. Also none of which is in this app is "You're" research.You may have coded it but all of that stuff was figured out before you.There's a difference. Take this how you may but this is only for you to improve if you so choose so. Alright thanks for your input. The settings don't reset they save it just doesn't show the current settings (In 1.4.1 I fixed that). The login can be disabled in the settings and I did obfuscate it, apparently its a bad obfuscator.... And what I mean by research is I got all the offsets and lengths for the stuff by myself, of course I didn't research the map file structure. Edited October 24, 2009 by halodu03de
halodu03de Posted October 24, 2009 Author Report Posted October 24, 2009 It's ***************************. I didn't even mean to release it, its my first app no shit its not gonna be amazing, and you don't have to use it I posted it for people who might be able to use it to help themselves.
Rogue Modder Posted October 24, 2009 Report Posted October 24, 2009 And what I mean by research is I got all the offsets and lengths for the stuff by myself, of course I didn't research the map file structure. But i gave you most of the source code for the apps in this with offsets, length, type ect. In, Thanks to DSS. :/
halodu03de Posted October 24, 2009 Author Report Posted October 24, 2009 But i gave you most of the source code for the apps in this with offsets, length, type ect. In, Thanks to DSS. :/ DSS? And no i actually didn't use any of the source you gave me. If you're talking about your mainmenu editor I didn't even try to decompile it because i wanted to do it myself.Just because you think I would doesn't mean I did.
NOPxK9 Posted October 24, 2009 Report Posted October 24, 2009 Looks werid, The code is shit. most is copy and pasted, very sloppy spilling resources EVERYWHERE!!! Yick. Another useless AIO 1
halodu03de Posted October 24, 2009 Author Report Posted October 24, 2009 Looks werid, The code is shit. most is copy and pasted, very sloppy spilling resources EVERYWHERE!!! Yick. Another useless AIO Maybe because its 20,000 lines.... Its my first app i doubt yours was better.
Rogue Modder Posted October 25, 2009 Report Posted October 25, 2009 Maybe because its 20,000 lines.... Its my first app i doubt yours was better. If you knew who that was, you wouldn't say that. Also, DSS = DarkSlipstream and he recognised the layout of the app to his own stuff.
halodu03de Posted October 25, 2009 Author Report Posted October 25, 2009 (edited) If you knew who that was, you wouldn't say that. Also, DSS = DarkSlipstream and he recognised the layout of the app to his own stuff. Well then we both did it similar ways >_>There arent many ways to do it and i doubt it is close to the same besides binary writer and binary reader.Idk who it is but at least my first app isnt a stupid webbrowser. Edit: Why does everything on this site have to be a flame war. If I say i ******* wrote the code then you should believe me. Edited October 25, 2009 by halodu03de 1
NOPxK9 Posted October 25, 2009 Report Posted October 25, 2009 lol. For my first AIO it only took around 1000 lines MAX. and thats terrible code.
halodu03de Posted October 25, 2009 Author Report Posted October 25, 2009 (edited) lol. For my first AIO it only took around 1000 lines MAX. and thats terrible code. Because i made most of the stuff in it. I know its terrible code lol but it works. Also, I never felt like going back and cleaning up all the code towards the beginning of the app so the newer code is cleaned up. Edited October 25, 2009 by halodu03de
JIME108 Posted October 25, 2009 Report Posted October 25, 2009 Maybe because its 20,000 lines.... Its my first app i doubt yours was better. It doesnt matter how many lines of code it has, I still think it's another shitty AIO.Release an app that actually meets the wants of the community.
halodu03de Posted October 25, 2009 Author Report Posted October 25, 2009 It doesnt matter how many lines of code it has, I still think it's another shitty AIO.Release an app that actually meets the wants of the community. Wow thanks for not saying something pointless. What SHOULD I make then now that I know most of the language.
Rogue Modder Posted October 25, 2009 Report Posted October 25, 2009 You know very little of the language, i know little myself, there is so much... Also, use your brain, think of a good app to make.
halodu03de Posted October 25, 2009 Author Report Posted October 25, 2009 You know very little of the language, i know little myself, there is so much... Also, use your brain, think of a good app to make. I know a lot compared to when I started C#
michael iz pro Posted October 25, 2009 Report Posted October 25, 2009 Great APP DUDE !!! +1 Halodu03de FTW !!!
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now