12 replies to this topic

[caratti]

Ok i see that i have been hurting people felling; people are saying Caratti is just leaving only bad feedback of my sig and nothing positive, first off im not going too: if i don't talk about it i don't have a problem with it. i only leave bad feedback so u can improve im not going to be a jerk and say its good even thought truly its garbage so im doing u a favor. you think i became good because i settled with a crappy sig no literally took 5 hours to make a sig i tried to make it best as possible i was my hardest critique some times would make a sig and delete it and start over cuz i know i can do it better. No one starts off good do u really think ur gfx gods "Anarchy" and "Cesar" (writing that made me laugh) stated off good it takes time. Even on a great sig i will find something to improve on. All im trying to say is "suck it up and try harder"

look i used to suck just like you~






hard work and you will get good~

Edited by caratti, 12 August 2008 - 02:20 AM.

[subs_55]

constructie critisism an needless, uncreative insults are different. you just flat out come up with a bad joke a say how bad it is by basshing its head in an offering little to no advice on how to fix it. but you do have meanning an good reasos behind your words in most cases you just go bout it way wrong.

now your proboly going to snap on me, but ya kow that would make you a hypocrit. complaining about people complaining about you being to harsh an giving advice, kinda exactly what i just did. funny eh?

[caratti]

i don't insult i say the truth and how i feel isnt that the whole point of showing off so you can see the reaction of other people?
i could be wrong though.......

and i don't get mad at people
that easily (only when people steal my killtac) so im not snapping on you only havening a civil argument by giving my
opinion on things

[Happy Buddah]

I 100% agree with subs. The last post you made in my gfx application was helpful, but any other post I've ever seen by you was just saying "It sucks," "It's a whales @$#%!$," or some other unnecessary comment. I'm not asking you to say bad work is good, I just don't think comments like that are going to get people anywhere... Honestly people are more likely to quit with those comments than to improve with them.

[.Slack♠]

well criticizm is criticizm and just the truth if he thinks its looks like a whale @$#%!$ then he must be pointing out that he really doesnt like it.

[.Slack♠]

sorry this was double posted and i cant find where to delete it

Edited by .Slack♠, 12 August 2008 - 09:39 AM.

[Happy Buddah]

Ok slack, but how is that going to help the other person??? In what way is that constructive?

[.dice♥]

i actually gotta agree with caratti. suck it up boys.

[sillybob123]

hmm although i feel some of your comments are un neccesary i again have to agree with him sometimes this kind of critism is needed in order to give us the push to better our work

[Happy Buddah]

Ok so next time somebody makes something I don't like I'll just tell thim it looks retarded.

[D.HeRo♥]

If you know your replys are just critque, then why create an entire topic explaining how you got better. Your so called critisism, is nothing. People that actually properly go over the sig say things about the details, instead of "looks like crap, start over." Sorry that not everyone can ***** c4ds and smudge like you, get your s*** straight and stop bein such a lil a$$HOLE...........................................give proper critique.

*Locked

Edited by D.HeRo♥, 14 August 2008 - 01:12 PM.

[.MeLo♥]

you used to suck
and still do

all that s*** you showed thats "good" is old as hell
and guarentee from tuts

[Xx Legacy xX]

you used to suck
and still do

all that s*** you showed thats "good" is old as hell
and guarentee from tuts

but we still <3 caratti (i get the feeling i am miss using my mod privileges)

lol look at my new work wow its prooooo


xD


-Legacy