17 replies to this topic

[.MeLo♥]

There were many disputes,
and people voted without leaving a comment, so here is what we are going to do

The only way to vote is to say who your voting for, no poll

And you must explain WHY you voted for that person.
Still to 7

D1CEx14 = 4


MeLo = 7


CLOSED

[Andrew_h]

I vote for Melo.
Dice's looks bad because her left arm looks distorted and huge, and Melo's looks simple, and well thought out.

[Laxmonster54♥]

I vote melo.
You guys both came up with amazing sigs and Dice that is the best sig Ive seen you make.
But melo Tried a harder style and succeed so I have to give him credit

[StevenSVE♥]

Melo is my Vote. Always a Fan of Naruto and nice sig, yours Dice was great but yeah, what Andrew said, her arm is big as hell.

[.dice♥]

hmm.. i guess you guys couldn't look past the arm illusion

[T3A guy]

i vote melo cuz it looks like u just merged 2 pictures dice.

[SmokiestGrunl]

I vote dice simply because I like the sig style better, I don't like "cartoon" type sigs. If it was a vote on pen tool yours wins.

[isaacmatthews]

Melo definatly, D1ce's arm looks funny lol

[D.HeRo♥]

I vote dice, sorry melo. Your pen-tooling is great, but too much of the same object repeated, mix it up with creativity great job, but no. I vote dice, because the sig has better flow, and i loves the text, even though he did screw up with the depth thing.

Sorry melo, but dice has my vote.

[Relapse]

i vote for D1CE

reason- jessica alba is fine

[blacklabelfosho]

DiceX

but thats bc you cant compete jessica alba with naruto.

she is just the sexayest woman alive

[.MeLo♥]

i vote for D1CE

reason- jessica alba is fine

not a real reason,
deosnt count

DiceX

but thats bc you cant compete jessica alba with naruto.

she is just the sexayest woman alive

Also not a reason,
sorry blacky it doesnt count

[chederz]

I vote Dice because it looks more creative and Melo's is a lot of repetition.

[.MeLo♥]

there really isnt repetition except for the red circles,
the waves fading with difcolors is sorta repetition i guess

Thanks for the feedback ill try to work on that

[Xx Anarchy xX♥]

melo
colouring is nice
style is refreshing from most of the things i have seen around here
a tip for next time though melo, the texture of the character and the BG and FG don't match
maybe vector him next time

[subs_55]

i vote dice. i like the vibe it gives off. it seams to flow well except for the arm which i didnt notice before. also jessica alba is amazing.

[iKhaosmaster]

i'm voting for melo because i like the way he used the pen tool and i like the style and the colors. And yay i'm the winning vote.

[.MeLo♥]

closed
i won